By Leanna Zamosc
As some articles have already stated, BBC stated that the U.K. public broadcaster initially felt that Benedict Cumberbatch was not sexy enough for the titular role of BBC’s Sherlock. This is really interesting information, as we all know that it was this show that began Cumberbatch’s popularity. Ever since the airing of the first season of Sherlock, Cumberbatch has become a sex icon and is labeled as one of the hottest men to ever exist. As a friend of likes to put it, he’s like wine—he ‘ages’ well and looks more and more handsome as time goes on.
So why did BBC’s public broadcaster fret about Cumberbatch’s looks for a show about Sherlock Holmes? After all, Sherlock Holmes is a character known for his genius, not his sexy looks. But apparently BBC wanted a sexy Sherlock and, ironically, they did get one.
What is interesting to me is that the “not sexy enough” situation also applied to Doctor Who’s David Tennant, who also ended up being considered as a sexy actor by many fans of the show.
So does BBC just have a bad sexy radar?
Another question I want to consider is how much tv shows influence our perception of what is beautiful or—to put it bluntly—sexy. It is through shows like Doctor Who and Sherlock where these actors get introduced and become famous. Most people don’t have to pay money to go to a movie theater to see these shows: they can just go onto the internet or watch it on tv. Not only that, but shows are a lot longer than movies—you see a tv actor playing a character for a long period of time.
I think that a part how tv affects our perception of beautiful people is the way that the characters are written—they fascinate us, we love them, and we have feelings about these characters that Cumberbatch and Tennant play. We love seeing them interact as the character, saying aloud the scripted words like an incantation that draws us in. We see the character as beautiful for their quirks, strengths, and flaws, and then we associate the actor to the character. For many people, Cumberbatch IS Sherlock Holmes, the quirky borderline-sociopathic genius that is learning how to deal with the people and world around him while he solves crimes. And it’s shocking really. It sounds almost delusional to say that people find Cumberbatch and Tennant attractive because they find Sherlock and The Doctor attractive. But in many situations, that seems to be the case.